Why hackers moved from vi readline mode to Emacs
1 hacker described this switch in public comments. Their words, with links to the originals.
What hackers said about the move
“I switched from vi readline mode to emacs recently primarily for Ctrl-r and Alt-. (insert the argument from the last command).”meken, 2026-09-16original comment ↗
Use vi readline mode? Get alerted when hackers criticize it.
Tell us the tools in your stack. When hackers start criticizing one of them, or moving to an alternative, you will hear about it first.
vi readline mode vs Emacs
| vi readline mode | Emacs | |
|---|---|---|
| Hackers who recommend | 0 | 8 |
| Hackers who criticize | 0 | 1 |
| Moved away from it | 1 | 1 |
| Moved to it | 0 | 4 |
Counts are distinct hackers in the sampled comments, not market share.
Criticism of vi readline mode
No further criticism of vi readline mode captured yet.
Praise for Emacs
“Same here! Aside from the basic unix tools in /[usr]/bin/, there is very little software with the longevity of emacs.”jjav, 2026-10-29original comment ↗
“I recently switched from full IDE to Emacs”KallDrexx, 2026-08-27original comment ↗
“My "stack" is all open-source: from Linux to Emacs to what-have-you.”TacticalCoder, 2026-05-04original comment ↗
“I switched from IntelliJ to emacs for this reason and it’s been great”ATMLOTTOBEER, 2026-03-26original comment ↗
“Emacs, for example, has rx notation.”db48x, 2026-01-28original comment ↗
Other moves from vi readline mode
Other moves to Emacs
- IntelliJ IDEA → Emacs (1)
- Neovim → Emacs (1)
- vi → Emacs (1)